The video will be available shortly.
Abstract
The " secret remedies " were at the heart of empiricists' and charlatans' activities in the 20th century XVIIIthcentury. We approach them today from two angles . On the one hand, the economy of privilege placed them at the heart of Ancien Régime society, rather than at its margins. Secondly, political and scientific authorities sought to regulate and control their trade. The first perspective allows us to reflect on the ambiguities of corporate privilege, by which the monarchy derogates from its own rules in favor of remedy merchants who escape common law.This is a situation we find on a European scale, notably in Italy and Germany, where the plurality of legal norms produces a blurring of regulations and competition between the corporatist system and merchant dynamics. Everywhere, current historiography is discovering the diversity of players and the porosity of borders. The category of " empirical " encompasses a huge variety of situations, from itinerant remedy merchants to innovative entrepreneurs, sometimes active on a European scale, who mobilize the language of the Enlightenment, produce scholarly attestations and develop branding strategies
In a second time, we look at the gradual establishment of monarchical control over secret remedies in France, with the secret remedy commissions (1728, 1772), then above all with the creation of the Royal Society of Medicine in 1778. Thanks to active collaboration with the lieutenancy general of police and the inspector in charge of controlling " empiriques ", the Society, under the impetus of Félix Vicq d'Azyr, controlled almost seven hundred recipes for medicines or cosmetics, and rejected almost 90 % of them. It applied three criteria - harmlessness, efficacy, novelty - and sometimes carried out analyses and experiments before granting its official authorizations or tacit permissions. Despite a great deal of police work and scientific expertise, control remained inadequate : many quacks were reluctant to submit their products, local authorities were uncooperative, and it seemed difficult to fight remedy sellers on the advertising front. In 1789, after a decade's work, the Royal Society of Medicine concluded that it had relatively failed : it did not have the means to prevent empiricists whose remedies had been rejected from continuing to sell and advertise them.
Bibliography
- Grégoire Chamayou, Les Corps vils. Expérimenter sur les êtres humains aux XVIIIthet XIXthsiècles, Paris, La Découverte, 2008.
- Vincent Demont, " Panacées ou faux remèdes ? Publicité médicale et langage des métiers (Nuremberg, fin XVIIth -début XVIIIthsiècle) ", Revue historique, forthcoming.
- " L'espérance privilégiée. Imperial grace and the urban medical market (Nuremberg, late XVIIth - early XVIIIthcentury)", Hoffnung handeln. L'espérance en action, Carnet de recherches de l'Institut historique allemand (Paris), 2024.
- Toby Gelfand, Professionalizing Modern Medicine: Paris Surgeons and Medical Science and Institutions in the 18th Century, Westport, Greenwood Press, 1980.
- Gabriel Galvez-Behar, Possessing science. La propriété scientifique au temps du capitalisme industriel, Éditions de l'EHESS, Paris, 2020.
- Pascale Gramain, " Le monde du médicament à l'aube de l'ère industrielle. Les enjeux de la prescription médicamenteuse de la fin du XVIIIthau début du XIXthsiècle ", PhD thesis, Université Paris 7, 1999.
- Charlotte Guichard, La Griffe du peintre. La valeur de l'art (1730-1820), Paris, Seuil, 2018.
- Caroline Hannaway, " The Royal Society of Medicine and Epidemics in the Ancien Régime ", Bulletin of the History of Medicine, vol. 46, no. 3, 1972, pp. 257-73.
- Catherine Lanoe, La Poudre et le Fard. Une histoire des cosmétiques, Seyssel, Champ Vallon, 2008.
- Alexandre Lunel, La Maison médicale du roi, XVIth -XVIIIthsiècles, Le pouvoir royal et les professions de santé, Seyssel, Champ Vallon, 2008.
- Dominique Margairaz and Myriam Tsikounas (dir.), Ce que signer veut dire. Sociétés & Représentations, vol. 25, 2008.
- Dominique Margairaz, Anne Conchon, Vincent Demont, Guillaume Garner, Pauline Lemaigre-Gaffier and Corine Maitte, L'Économie des grâces. Les privilèges d'entreprise dans l'Europe moderne, XVth - XVIIIthsiècles, to be published by IGPDE (Institut de la gestion publique et du développement économique), Histoire économique et financière de la France collection, 2026.
- Sabrina Minuzzi, ""Quick to say Quack". Medicinal Secrets from the Household to the Apothecary's Shop in Eighteenth-century Venice", Social History of Medicine, vol. 32, no. 1, 2019, pp. 1-33.
- Bérangère Pinaud, " Le travail, les savoirs et le quotidien dans le monde des apothicaires parisiens (années 1690-1777) ", EHESS doctoral dissertation, 2024.
- Matthew Ramsey, Professional and Popular Medicine in France, 1770-1830: The Social World of Medical Practice, Cambridge University Press, 1988).
- " Traditional Medicine and Medical Enlightenment: The Regulation of Secret Remedies in the Ancien Régime ", Historical Reflections/Réflexions historiques, vol. 9, n°1/2, 1982, p. 215-32.
- Philip Rieder and François Zanetti (eds.), Materia medica. Savoirs et usages des médicaments aux époques médiévales et modernes, Geneva, Droz, 2018.